Monday, June 13, 2011

The Walker Hitler Comparisson

It is a sad twist of fate that now when we really need to hold up Hitler and the Nazis as the  example of how fascists gain power and behave when they "govern" we can't because of the furor and distractions that come from the atrocities they committed after coming to power.  No one is accusing Scott Walker of wanting to kill six million Jews or any similar atrocity.  The current discussion shouldn't be about what was done once power was consolidated but how power was consolidated that let such atrocities be committed. 

The relevant comparison is the how both use the usurpation of the democratic process and government transparency and replace it with a single party despotism that is sold by  wealthy elites as democracy to the general population using corporate/state media.  Again I am not comparing Walker to Hitler or implying he has any intention or ability to commit atrocities on the level of Hitler and the Nazis.  What I am saying is we would be foolish to ignore the lessons of Hitler and the Nazis methods for consolidating power as the techniques Walker and the Wisconsin GOP are using are similar.

The other lesson is that that level of consolidated power is dangerous and historically has lead to abuse.  We don't know yet what Walker and his cronies would do completely unfettered.  What we have seen so far does not bode well for dissidents, the poor, the working poor, the working, immigrants, people of color, the GLBT community, students, and organized labor.  At this point we have a strong federal government that should limit the type of atrocities that often happen when fascists take over at a federal level.

At a smaller scale many of the current policies being pursued by this administration are going to needlessly impoverish, kill or speed up the death of many people via their legislative attacks on healthcare for the poor, women and the elderly as well as direct attacks and the poor and working poor.  Although these actions are not as obvious and not at the historic world shaking scale of Hitler and the Nazis or Pol Pot, Stalin, Pinochet or any other Fascist dictator you would like to reference, to a decent, conscientious human being these unnecessary and pointless deaths by the pen still qualify as an atrocity.

There it is done.  My first post as a blogger I have committed legitimacy suicide by making the one comparison that can no longer be made in polite company without being completely marginalized even if it is true.

No comments:

Post a Comment